← Back to show

Archived forum thread

ETS Tour Journal

2005/11/26 - Sao Paulo, Brazil [Claro Festival]

16 Posts
2005-11-26 Show date
Claro Festival Venue
Site Admin
2005/11/26 - Sao Paulo, Brazil [Claro Festival]
Please post all reviews, setlists, photographs, etc. here. This thread is reserved for attendees of the show only; do not post if you did not attend the show. You do not need to register to post in this thread, but if you already have an account, it is recommended to log in. Registered users can upload photos.
Bricklayer
These guys played for 1 hours exactly... it´s sucks but fuck that... I liked!!!
I´m gonna try to post the setlist:
Wish
Sin
March of the pigs
The line begins to blur
Terrible lie
Burn
Fragile
With teeth
Closer
Only
Hurt
The hand that feeds
Head like a hole

No comments, i watch them in the first ones, very close of the stage...
Soon I´ll post some pics and the video that i did...
Peace,
Arnaldo......................................
no, they didn't play the fragile, but frail/wretched.
Bricklayer
Fragile?? Hmm actually it was The Frail/The Wretched.. wow it was just great!!! Didnt stay with the crowd (vip section actually) but it was awesome!! We got Sin!!!! Few songs, but anyway, i reeaaally enjoyed it, first concert i've ever gone, and a NIN one!!!!!!! I still can't believe i listened to all those songs live! And see them just some feet away...O_o
Man, Aaron went crazy up there hahaa really awesome.. and trent went into the crowd!! lucky bastards there in the front ¬¬
Well, now i just hope they enjoyed it and plan to come back here!! xD
There are some pics here but not really good ones, but anyway:
http://musica.uol.com.br/album/claro07_ ... album.jhtm
The show was awesome. They played about to 1 hour and 15 minutes.
Soon I will post some pictures here too.

Here is the correct Set list:

- Wish
- Sin
- The Line Begins to Blur
- March of Pigs
- Terrible Lie
- The Frail
- The Wretched
- Closer (More guitar version)
- Burn
- With Teeth
- Only
- Suck
- Hurt (Piano and Voice almost the whole song, only in the final the rest of band played, the song was slower than usual)
- The Hand That Feeds
- Head Like a Hole (They smashed up their guitars and keyborads in the end of that)

I wish thay played more songs, but this 15 songs were perfects, band perfomance, lights, quality of the sound, the whole production is very very well done.
This is the best concert I´ve ever seen.

Sorry for my bad English...
Master of the Ninth Arch
The show was perfect, as usual, but too short.

I took some pictures to post here as soon as I find my way home.

I'm simply describing this as a punch with all possible cruelty. No Intro, no Pinion, simply hitting our stomach directly with the lovely ballad Wish. A guy in the crowd told me before the show that they had in the setlist Deadsouls (haha), no Sin and a lot of shit. I even met Rob and Alessandro. Nice guys, at least during our 10 sec. long conversation.

Please! Come back soon.

I will not risk my life going to Rio just because I don't know anyone there.
It was great to see them, but after 11 years waiting to see NIN it was frustrating to listen only 15 songs. Aparently Trent got crossed because the band was not playing very well (I did not notice any problems though) and decided to finish the gig earlier.
The lights were really amazing! I was glad they brought all the production.
I thought the audience was a bit quiet. I was afraid to be in the front, but no problems.

Went to the hotel afterwards, Trent had gone to his bedroom cause they had to leave for Rio early morning. Only the drummer was there.

I definetely have to see them again.
charlottesixx wrote:...it was frustrating to listen only 15 songs. Aparently Trent got crossed because the band was not playing very well (I did not notice any problems though) and decided to finish the gig earlier.
It was probably due to the fact that it was a festival with other bands, not just a NIN show exclusivley....
Bricklayer
Actually the show was 50 min. long. I took the time. Trent did a very personal performance, without communicating with the audience very often... I don't know if he usually does that, this was my first NIN concert. Well, the show was short, I heard a lot of people complaining about that. I did not noticed that trent got crossed cause the band wasn't playing well. I think the music, lights performance, everything was perfect. And with Iggy's show before (fuckin amazing!!!!!), people were pumped up to see what the fuck was gonna happen!!! Too bad they didn't played the whole Broken album in the show... hehehe!!! Well, at least gave up!!! But no complaints!!! The show was A+! Twiggy Ramirez was a bit quiet on the stage though...
Master of the Ninth Arch
Damn Christian we could not meet each other in the show, cause it’s was really crazy in the pit area. São Paulo crowd was very violent and drunk. I saw a lot people pass out even before the international acts hit the stage. And survive the pit on Iggy shows was the most hardcore thing I had to do. I am also glad that I did not pass out with Lee Ranaldo and Thurston Moore’s guitar distortion. That one was beyond disturbing.
If we meet, we could help you to get in Rio. You missed a great act. They did Repitle, Starfuckers in there and of course, the band was great and more comfortable and TR is nice and chatty. And the crowd was much nicer. We even could talk a little bit with Sweeney. Great guy. I am so thankful for Trent giving one of the best moments of my life.
I am on my way to change money and pack to Buenos Aires. I bring more news when I come back.
Master of the Ninth Arch
NotFrustated wrote:It was probably due to the fact that it was a festival with other bands, not just a NIN show exclusivley....
They had to end the show @ 3am. This is the reason for the short setlist.

Capricorn, I will reply your post soon.
Bricklayer
As I read on the net, Trent did't like the performance of the band in SP, so that's why they didn't do an encore (they're supposed to play Starfuckers Inc.). I read that the band wanted to play a little more, but Trent went straight to the van. Actually, the only thing that made me really mad about the SP show compared to the Rio show is the fact that i missed the band play "Gave up". Shit!!! My favorite song and they play it only in Rio... oh well, what the fuck!!! The show was great anyway. No complaints... at all!!!!!
Master of the Ninth Arch
The Wretched Live From Sao Paulo

mms://200.169.96.77/04/claronine001.wmv
"survive the pit on Iggy shows was the most hardcore thing I had to do"
Couldn't agree with you more. I had a broken arm so I stayed on the first row so I could try to hold on to the fence and protect myself, but it didn't quite work, for the crowd was wild during Iggy show, and when he asked the public to join him on stage people just started trowing themselves over whoever /whatever was in front of them - so I got hit on the head several times. But, as sore and bruised as I got, I just managed to stay there through the whole thing so I could actually see the NIN show close enough. And I am SO glad I did. It was totally fucking awesome! I still get the goosebumps when I think about it. During Closer Trent went down the stage to the pit and everybody just piled up to touch him (and, allowing myself a moment of crazy-fan-gone-wild, I did it too... I was thrilled, hehe). The whole show was very straight to the point, no "I love you sao paolo" shit, but you could feel just how pleased they were to be playing there, the way the crowd was reacting - specially during "Hurt", with moments of silence and them a whisper slowly growing as the whole crowd was singing along... beautiful! Maybe people were not as wild as one would expect, but that was beacuse everybody was just amazed, watching the show with a mixture of bedazzlement and respect (most people waited for this gig for more than ten years, so they were just not in the "let's get wasted" mood). As far as I know, the media has been working hard on spreading this version of the facts were Trent was not pleased with the performance and just decide to finish early, but for what I know he was pissed at the festival organization (as Iggy was, and that's why he kicked the cameras and spit at the reporters on stage - but that's not the official version, they keep saying he was just doing his wild act, but those who were close enoug to see and hear know how it happened). Apparently the organizers did't allow an encore because they had to leave soon so they could get to Rio on time, and even so some of the equipment didn't make it on time and they had to perform without most of the screens and scenery (and three hours late). Oh well, I can only hope they were not too disapointed with this, and will come back to Brazil with their own show, and not with one of those crappy festivals.