All right, here's my take on the show. Let's start with the disappointments:
1) No pilgremage OR Mr. Self Destruct. It would've made my year to see those live.
2) No Dead Souls, no Something....oh well, I can live without I guess
3) Not being able to hear Trent sing during the chorus of Hurt. It's a heartfelt song guys; let him sing it. yeesh.
Now, on to the good:
-Two hour set (ended earlier than normal because it started earlier than normal...make sense, everyone?)
-The Day the World Went Away. It's been one of my favorites, and I was surprised to hear it. Surprised, and very happy
-The speech. It sounds like Trent isn't much of a talker during shows, so I was really caught off guard when he said what he did. It knocked him off the big rockstar pedestal that I'd had him on and made me realize that he's just a regular guy....really talented, but otherwise he's just like you or me.
-The Only Time breakdown. At first I was little bummed about it, because I had always wanted to hear the bass from the original version just shake through my bones in an arena. But they still set the EQ so that the Jeordie did just that with the alternate version. Very nice

-Eraser. I was near the side of the stage, so I could watch everyone playing clearly while that was going on, and it was great to see Jeordie up there actually playing the whole thing on bass, and not having Alessando just hitting a few loops on the synths.
Other major disappointment: I ran into a bunch of friends while I was there, and being the only one that isn't 21 yet, I didn't get a chance to go out after the show. But that's not NIN's fault
All in all, I think it was worth the wait. May not have lived up entirely to my hopes, but still a damn fine show nonetheless.